Menu Close

Setting Target Weights in Eating Disorder Treatment

Review the Patient’s Growth History

After an eating disorder diagnosis, it is important to determine whether the patient’s disordered eating behaviors have artificially changed body composition and weight, regardless of diagnosis. This allows the treatment team to make a plan for how to achieve nutritional rehabilitation, which is a critical first step in recovering from any eating disorder. This restoration of medical health is important for regaining mental and medical stability. With eating disorder restriction, most patients lose muscle and necessary fat stores as well as deplete vital organs, bone, and tissue as the body tries to cope with malnutrition — regardless of body fat or appearance. With those who experience loss of control eating or purge after eating, body weight may be in or above average range, but the inconsistency of nutrition can affect metabolism and growth.

Unfortunately there is no common standard among clinicians or fields for setting target weights and ranges. In addition, many insurance carriers cover only emergency conditions so patients are released or care is ended before true recovery. Failure to reach and maintain a metabolically healthy body stalls recovery and leads to relapse and chronic illness.

Parents need to know: target weights and ranges are not an exact science, each patient will have a healthy weight range that is unique to their biology and their development, weight ranges change over time, maintaining a weight range lower than metabolically healthy for the individual keeps the patient from full mental recovery.

Lifetime growth charts

Many clinics now use lifetime height and weight charts to determine where a patient would have been had the illness not altered growth. This is especially helpful for patients whose weight is considered “normal” in terms of BMI but mental or other measures indicate a problem. It is possible for a person to have a “normal” BMI but still be significantly underweight for his or her own frame and physiology. Parents can plot their child’s growth on the following charts, or obtain growth records from their child’s regular physician. If the child stops following their own personal growth trajectory, it may be an indication of ill health or nutrition. The lifetime growth curve can also help set initial weight gain goals during weight restoration.

Online Children’s BMI Percentage Calculator (ages 2-20 girls & boys)

Ideal Body Weight (IBW)

Although calculators exist on the Internet for IBW,there is no agreed upon standard for calculation. The Mclaren, Moore, and BMI calculations fail to take age, development, and genetic factors into consideration.

BMI

BMI is a controversial measurement that has become ubiquitous in modern society. A ratio using height and weight, BMI does not take into account body composition or whether the patient is healthy. BMI is a population screening tool that offers a view to where someone’s weight/height compare to others. It does not differentiate between fat/muscle mass, so athletes will often have BMI’s deemed: “overweight.” By definition, the BMI curve allows for perfectly healthy people on the high and the low end of the scale – it also tells us nothing about the actual health of the person it is measuring. It is especially difficult to use BMI to evaluate growing children as they go through growth spurts and may be delayed from illness. Many eating disorder clinics and clinicians do use a mid-range BMI standard (20-22) as an initial goal, reassessing as patient’s health improves.

Hormone levels

Malnourishment, even small amounts less than needed, causes the body to cease non-essential functions. Fertility and sex drive are some of the first functions that the body and brain shut down to save energy. For girls, resumption of regular menstruation can be an indicator of maintaining sustainable weight and body composition. For boys the signs are more difficult to discern, but include a resumption of nocturnal emissions and interest in sex. *Special note on the use of birth control pills in eating disorder patients.

Family History

Healthy body composition, weight, and height are largely determined by genetics. While tall blonde parents may occasionally give birth to short brunettes, most of the time children look – and at healthy weights are shaped – like their relatives. Twins raised separately generally have similar adult weights, for example. Family history is often used to help determine whether a patient is in a normal weight range and target weights should take genetics into account.

Body composition analysis

Some clinics use body composition analysis in determining whether a patient is maintaining a healthy weight. This calculation of lean body mass and fat can be helpful in assessing weight goals.

Indirect Calorimetry

Measuring Resting Energy Expenditure (REE) is one way to determine the metabolic rate and use of calories in a recovering patient. This is measured through direct or indirect calorimetry

Pelvic ultrasound and menstrual status for female patients

For female patients, an ultrasound of the ovaries can determine whether the patient is ovulating, and give an indication of reproductive health. Although menstrual status has long been used as a measure of severity of anorexia, it has lost favor as a diagnostic tool. Patients with chronic malnutrition have in significant numbers continued to menstruate, and patients who are fully recovered may still not resume normal periods. Click here for a protocol for this approach.

Vital signs

Some physicians find it helpful to use vital signs like heart rate and orthostatic blood pressure changes to determine whether a patient has stabilized and is functioning normally. Other indications include: normal body temperature, coloring, pulse, and how fast skin pressed with a fingernail returns to a normal color (capillary refill).

Blood tests

It is common for clinicians to do blood tests during diagnosis and evaluation. However, parents should not be relieved by “normal” lab reports. Sadly, blood tests are not a good indication of health: the body compensates for malnutrition and a patient can have “normal” measures almost until death. Tests for levels of sex hormones are often done to determine whether levels suppressed by malnutrition have returned to normal levels (this can take months after reaching and maintaining a healthy weight range.)

Parent intuition

Many parents report developing an intuitive sense of a loved one’s weight range stability through behavior. As a patient settles into physical health there are also subtle signs of emotional stability, flexibility, and increased ability to reason. Likewise, parents report knowing when things have slipped out of range through behavior and attitude.

Review the Patient’s Growth History

After an eating disorder diagnosis, it is important to determine whether the patient’s disordered eating behaviors have artificially changed body composition and weight, regardless of diagnosis. This allows the treatment team to make a plan for how to achieve nutritional rehabilitation, which is a critical first step in recovering from any eating disorder. This restoration of medical health is important for regaining mental and medical stability. With eating disorder restriction, most patients lose muscle and necessary fat stores as well as deplete vital organs, bone, and tissue as the body tries to cope with malnutrition — regardless of body fat or appearance. With those who experience loss of control eating or purge after eating, body weight may be in or above average range, but the inconsistency of nutrition can affect metabolism and growth.

Unfortunately there is no common standard among clinicians or fields for setting target weights and ranges. In addition, many insurance carriers cover only emergency conditions so patients are released or care is ended before true recovery. Failure to reach and maintain a metabolically healthy body stalls recovery and leads to relapse and chronic illness.

Parents need to know: target weights and ranges are not an exact science, each patient will have a healthy weight range that is unique to their biology and their development, weight ranges change over time, maintaining a weight range lower than metabolically healthy for the individual keeps the patient from full mental recovery.

The very popular Poodle Science video explains normal weight and shape.

Read about How Child’s Growth Charts And Eating Disorders: Identify a problem early By Lauren Muhlheim, PsyD, CEDS, F.E.A.S.T. Advisor 

Published by permission from creator, Eva Musby